|Year : 2022 | Volume
| Issue : 2 | Page : 180-189
A pilot study regarding the consequences of the COVID-19 pandemic on healthcare education in India and the implications
Paras Sharma1, Kona Chowdhury2, Santosh Kumar3, Rohan Bhatt4, Tanvi Hirani3, Shilpa Duseja3, Mainul Haque5, Afzalunnessa Binte Lutfor6, Ayukafangha Etando7, Ranko Škrbić8, Moyad Shahwan9, Ammar Abdulrahman Jairoun10, Brian Godman11
1 Department of Pharmacognosy, BVM College of Pharmacy, Gwalior-474006, India
2 Department of Pediatrics, Gonoshasthaya Samaj Vittik Medical College and Hospital, Dhaka, Bangladesh
3 Department of Periodontology and Implantology, Karnavati School of Dentistry, Karnavati University, Uvarsad, Gandhinagar, Gujarat, India
4 Department of Periodontology, Karnavati School of Dentistry, Karnavati University, Uvarsad, Gandhinagar, Gujarat, India
5 Unit of Pharmacology, Faculty of Medicine and Defence Health, Universiti Pertahanan Nasional Malaysia (National Defence University of Malaysia), Kem Perdana Sungai, Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia
6 Department of Microbiology, Ad-Din Women's Medical College, Dhaka, Bangladesh
7 Department of Medical Laboratory Sciences, Faculty of Health Sciences, Eswatini Medical Christian University, Mbabane, Kingdom of Eswatini
8 Department of Pharmacology, Toxicology and Clinical Pharmacology, Medical Faculty, University of Banja Luka, Banja Luka, Republic of Srpska, Bosnia and Herzegovina
9 College of Pharmacy and Health Science, Ajman University; Centre of Medical and Bio-Allied Health Sciences Research, Ajman University, Ajman, United Arab Emirates
10 Department of Health and Safety, Dubai Municipality, Dubai, United Arab Emirates
11 Centre of Medical and Bio-Allied Health Sciences Research, Ajman University, Ajman, United Arab Emirates; Department of Pharmacoepidemiology, Strathclyde Institute of Pharmacy and Biomedical Sciences, University of Strathclyde, Glasgow, United Kingdom; Division of Public Health Pharmacy and Management, School of Pharmacy, Sefako Makgatho Health Sciences University, Ga-Rankuwa, South Africa
|Date of Submission||14-Feb-2022|
|Date of Decision||08-Mar-2022|
|Date of Acceptance||11-Mar-2022|
|Date of Web Publication||29-Apr-2022|
Department of Pharmacoepidemiology, Strathclyde Institute of Pharmacy and Biomedical Sciences, University of Strathclyde, Glasgow G4 0RE
Unit of Pharmacology, Faculty of Medicine and Defence Health, Universiti Pertahanan Nasional Malaysia (National Defence University of Malaysia), Kem Perdana Sungai, Besi, 57000 Kuala Lumpur
Source of Support: None, Conflict of Interest: None
Introduction: The early approaches to prevent the spread of COVID-19 included lockdown and social distancing measures, leading to university closures. These measures forced unparalleled changes to the delivery of healthcare education. Concerns included the preparedness of faculty and students to e-learning as well as the routine availability and funding of equipment and internet bundles. This needed addressing with fully trained healthcare professionals required given rising inappropriate use of antibiotics in India, growing prevalence of non-communicable diseases as well as an increasing number of patients with joint comorbidities. Consequently, there is a need to ascertain the current impact of the pandemic on healthcare student education across India. Materials and Methods: This was a pilot study among 10 purposely selected healthcare educators in both private and public universities. The questionnaire built on published studies. Results: Identified challenges included a lack of familiarity with online education, no bedside teaching, lack of equipment and affordability of internet bundles, poor internet connectivity and postponed examinations. Ways forward included training faculty on e-learning, providing students with loans and other financial support to purchase equipment and internet bundles, establishing COVID-19 prevention protocols and protective equipment, recording lectures and tutorials to make up for lost time and simulated methods to teach clinical aspects. Conclusion: Despite challenges, there was a rapid move to online learning among surveyed universities. Alongside this, courses to address lack of familiarity with e-learning approaches with hybrid teaching approaches here to stay. The next step will be to undertake a wider study and to use the combined findings to provide future guidance.
Keywords: COVID-19, education, healthcare, implications, India, pandemic
|How to cite this article:|
Sharma P, Chowdhury K, Kumar S, Bhatt R, Hirani T, Duseja S, Haque M, Lutfor AB, Etando A, Škrbić R, Shahwan M, Jairoun AA, Godman B. A pilot study regarding the consequences of the COVID-19 pandemic on healthcare education in India and the implications. Adv Hum Biol 2022;12:180-9
|How to cite this URL:|
Sharma P, Chowdhury K, Kumar S, Bhatt R, Hirani T, Duseja S, Haque M, Lutfor AB, Etando A, Škrbić R, Shahwan M, Jairoun AA, Godman B. A pilot study regarding the consequences of the COVID-19 pandemic on healthcare education in India and the implications. Adv Hum Biol [serial online] 2022 [cited 2023 Apr 1];12:180-9. Available from: https://www.aihbonline.com/text.asp?2022/12/2/180/344807
| Introduction|| |
COVID-19 has appreciably impacted on morbidity and mortality across countries since it was first identified in Wuhan, China, in December 2019, with 5.76 million deaths recorded by 7th February 2022., India is no exception, with over half a million deaths by the early February 2022. At the start of the pandemic, there were no proven effective treatments despite claims to the contrary for treatments including hydroxychloroquine and anti-viral medicines including remdesivir, with a number of these medicines subsequently failing to demonstrate improvements in patient care in well-controlled large-scale clinical studies.,,,, Consequently, activities undertaken by governments and others across countries at the start of the pandemic to limit its spread and impact centred on lockdown and other measures. Measures introduced included quarantining as well as the closure of borders and educational establishments including universities.,,,
However, the lockdown measures introduced early in India,, including the closure of schools and universities, coupled with the need to rapidly transform learning, including skills learning, online with associated challenges,,, appreciably impacted on the education of healthcare professionals (HCPs) across India, with a similar situation in Africa. Before this, campus-focussed teaching–learning activities encompassing face-to-face interactions with students, case-based learning and work-integrated learning were normal practice for all healthcare students.,, These forced changes resulted in unparalleled commotion and substantial challenges in HCP education across countries.,,,,,
These forced changes in the education of HCPs are a concern if these adversely impact on their necessary skills on graduation to effectively treat patients. We are already seeing the re-emergence of viral diseases in India coupled with the emergence of new viral diseases in addition to COVID-19., This rise adds further pressure on HCPs regarding the effective management of these existing and emerging diseases, with India already having a considerable infectious disease burden. This burden is reflected by India currently being the largest, or one of the largest, consumers of antibiotics worldwide, with usage rates continuing to grow.,, This high usage of antibiotics in India is exacerbated by considerable inappropriate prescribing and dispensing of antibiotics in ambulatory care in India. This includes fixed-dose combinations with utlisation of antibiotics enhanced by appreciable sales of antibiotics among community pharmacies without a prescription despite on-going legislation.,,,, Such practices are enhanced by currently a limited number of physicians in India, especially in rural areas, the convenience of community pharmacists and high levels of patient co-payments for both physician visits and medicines. Alongside this, pharmacists wishing to retain patients if they request antibiotics based on their previous experiences.
Out-of-pocket payments have remained relatively stable in India in recent years at between 63% and over 71% of total healthcare expenditure,,, with the cost of medicines accounting for an appreciable proportion of this., This is a concern as high out-of-pocket payments can have catastrophic consequences for some families when family members become ill., This is beginning to change in India with new reforms providing health insurance cover for a number of families. Alongside this, the Indian government has made a commitment to reduce out-of-pocket expenditures to 50% of total healthcare expenditures in the coming years. This however will take time necessitating trained HCPs to be fully aware of the circumstances of their patients and the cost of care, including medicines, when managing their condition. We are also aware of high levels of inappropriate prescribing of antibiotics for both adults and children in hospitals in India., Such activities are exacerbated by currently considerable prescribing of antibiotics to patients with suspected or actual COVID-19, mimicking other countries, despite limited evidence of concomitant bacterial co-infections.,,,,,
High rates of inappropriate prescribing of antimicrobials are a concern as this increases antimicrobial resistance (AMR) rates, with a corresponding impact on morbidity, mortality and costs.,, Concerns have grown regarding rising AMR rates during the current COVID-19 pandemic with, as mentioned, high levels of inappropriate antimicrobial prescribing, which need to be urgently addressed., We have seen that the instigation of antimicrobial stewardship programmes (ASPs) in hospitals in low- and middle-income countries (LMICs) improves appropriate antimicrobial prescribing despite resource issues and should be taken forward across India to improve future use.,,, However, we are aware that there can be concerns with knowledge regarding ASPs among physicians and other key stakeholders in hospitals in LMICs, which also needs to be addressed starting with undergraduate education., The instigation of appropriate educational activities among healthcare students can address knowledge concerns.,,
We have also seen that trained pharmacists can reduce inappropriate dispensing of antibiotics without a prescription as well as direct patients to more appropriate treatments, especially for viral and other self-limiting infections.,,, Fully trained community pharmacists can also help address the considerable misinformation that has existed surrounding potential treatments for COVID-19, including hydroxychloroquine, and provide appropriate advice.,,, High inappropriate use of hydroxychloroquine has been an issue across countries as this increases morbidity, mortality and costs.,, Trained physicians and pharmacists can also address important issues surrounding vaccine hesitancy, including COVID-19 vaccines, starting in university and following graduation.
Of equal importance in India are concerns with rising rates of non-communicable diseases (NCDs), with NCDs now being the principal cause of death in the country.,, Expenditures are exacerbated by the complications arising from NCDs, which can be addressed through improved prevention and adherence to prescribed medicines including through telemedicine approaches., Patient education via community pharmacists can also enhance adherence to medicines, with community pharmacists also helping to ensure medicine availability, which has been a concern during the current pandemic.,,, The public health issues arising from increasing rates of infectious diseases, AMR and NCDs, coupled with increasing rates of patients with combined comorbidities, must be reflected in university courses, including hybrid courses, to improve future patient care.
However, the initial challenges to HCP education across countries, including India, following closure of the universities included limited knowledge and experience with e-learning among both faculty members and students, a lack of infrastructure and equipment, concerns with academic integrity, including conducting examinations online, regular access to quiet rooms as well as the availability, reliability and costs of the internet including internet bundles coupled with the routine availability of electricity.,,,,, These challenges resulted in some universities postponing learning and teaching until key issues, including a lack of information technology, could be addressed. Alongside this, there have been concerns with conducting practicals and clinical rotations via e-learning due to social distancing and other important aspects potentially reducing necessary skills on graduation unless proactively addressed.,,,,,,, The challenges with lockdown, coupled with concerns with e-learning and future employment, has also resulted in increased mental health issues among both faculty members and students across countries.,,, This includes medical students in India.
The situation seen among a number of LMICs can be very different from higher-income countries with their greater resources and typically greater use of e-learning approaches before the start of the pandemic.,,, This is reflected in the study of Abbasi et al., who found greater satisfaction with e-learning experiences among students from developed versus developing countries. However, this is not universal, with Besche et al. reporting that an appreciable number of students at Harvard Medical School were also struggling with basic remote learning exacerbated by issues with Internet connectivity and quiet spaces to take part in remote classes and study. Conversely, students in Latvia, Nepal, the Republic of Srpska (Bosnia and Herzegovina) and Slovenia were generally satisfied with e-learning approaches, although there can still be technical issues, including connectivity issues.,,
We are aware that there have been studies conducted in India to assess the impact of lockdown and other measures, including the closure of universities, on the education of HCPs. These include concerns with a small number of healthcare students (23%) unable to attend online classes, issues with the household environment and internet connectivity, especially in rural areas,, and a greater preference for face-to-face teaching, especially among faculty members. Key issues include internet connectivity, poor audio and visual quality and reduced student engagement during online classes. Ray et al. also documented concerns with technical issues and concentration during online classes as well as issues with simulated technology and simulated patients for surgical training. Saurabh et al. also documented concerns with internet connectivity in over a third of medical students surveyed, with a higher number concerned with their ability to ask questions during online teaching sessions. However, Kaur et al. ascertained that among medical students in India, there were positive comments toward e-learning, including offering a better understanding of the subject matter through recorded classes. However, there were concerns including learning the necessary skills for a professional career postgraduation as well as balancing theoretical and practical knowledge with full-time e-learning.
A number of steps have been taken to address identified challenges in India. These include rapidly conducting online teaching sessions using a free version of Zoom® and subsequently buying an advanced version to enhance interaction with students at Pt. B. D. Sharma Postgraduate Institute of Medical Sciences in Haryana. Alongside this, Parul University rapidly implemented video-conference platforms resulting in 54.8% of medical students surveyed being extremely or quite satisfied with the online teaching modalities. Nimavat et al. also believed that the challenges with e-learning can be addressed, thereby improving the flexibility of learning, and consequently, the authors believed that such approaches are here to stay., However, key issues remain including considerable concerns with postgraduate training after the pandemic, which also needs to be addressed going forward in India and wider.,,,,
We wanted to build on these documented challenges and activities in India by undertaking a survey among faculty members attending both private and public healthcare universities. Potential participants should also include faculty personnel from universities training medical, dental and pharmacy students. This is because most published studies concentrate on different healthcare student populations rather than combining them. This started with a pilot study. The findings from this pilot study, coupled with those from subsequent studies, can be used to help improve the education of HCPs in India during a pandemic. This is especially important in India given, as mentioned, rising rates of both infectious diseases, NCDs and those with multiple comorbidities. In addition, an environment that is still heavily dependent on patient co-pays for financing recommended treatments.
| Materials and Methods|| |
This pilot study used a realistic exploratory approach based on a representational model among medical, dental and pharmacy faculty members across India. The objective was to understand the impact of COVID-19 on teaching and learning practices among HCPs, and potential ways forward, during these unprecedented times in India based on the experiences of faculty members. This method was built on the recently conducted studies among healthcare faculty members in Africa and Bangladesh involving a number of the authors.,
India currently has 595 medical colleges, which are either public, private, government-society or public or private trusts in line with the National Medical Commission (NMC) of India. However, while the country has several types of medical school, a unique curriculum operates among all medical schools in India., Similarly, India currently has over 300 dental colleges,,, with a similar course programme throughout India designed by the Dental Council of India. India also currently has more than 3000 pharmacy colleges registered with the Pharmacy Council of India (PCI), with pharmacy education regulated by the PCI with unique coursework across India., Both private and public healthcare universities were included in this pilot study as resources and equipment are likely to be greater among private universities and their students.
As mentioned, the questionnaire was developed based on the recent study undertaken across Africa regarding the impact of COVID-19 on medical and pharmacy education, combined with a similar study conducted in Bangladesh among senior medical, dental and health-professional educators.
The study questionnaire contained four open-ended questions to address the aims and objectives of the study. Participants were given an option to submit up to five responses. In addition, five more questions were included to elicit their response to support the first four questions.
The questions were:
- What challenges has COVID-19 presented to health sciences education in India?
- How did health sciences institutions respond immediately to the challenges presented by the COVID-19 pandemic in India?
- What support was harnessed to mitigate the challenges faced by higher learning institutions in India?
- What lessons can be learnt to prepare higher learning institutions in health sciences education for future pandemics?
- Did all students have access to the necessary equipment, e.g., computers, to undertake e-learning at the start of the pandemic, especially given comments in question 4? If not – how was this addressed in reality?
- Could all students afford the various internet bundles to undertake e-learning at the start of the pandemic? If not, what was being done about this?
- Were any courses/tutorials instigated early by the health science schools at the start of the pandemic for the teachers to become familiar with the new platforms such as Zoom®
- Were there any challenges with students undertaking e-learning at home, including access to a quiet room and reliable internet facilities?
- Have any support services been introduced for students and lecturers due to the pandemic? If so, please describe.
The questionnaire was subsequently distributed to 10 senior-level educators among seven Indian states (Bihar, Telangana, Uttar Pradesh, Gujarat, Karnataka, Madhya Pradesh and Maharashtra) in both public and private colleges who volunteered to be part of the pilot study using a purposeful sampling approach. If needed, one co-author consolidated the responses from their institution to help with the analysis. The answers to the open-ended questions were analysed into themes to aid the interpretation of the findings. The findings can help determine whether the pilot questionnaire needed any adaptation before undertaking the full study across India. No students were approached since we wanted to understand the challenges from faculty members first.
There was no need for ethical approval; this study was not dealing with patients. This is similar to the situation among other similar studies conducted by the co-authors across different areas.,,,,
| Results|| |
Ten educators took part, five from public universities and five from private universities. The educators covered a range of disciplines including applied therapeutics and pharmacology, paediatrics, pathology, and radiodiagnosis as well as conservative dentistry and endodontics, periodontics and prosthodontics, and pharmacy.
[Table 1] summarises the top six challenges faced by faculty members at the start of the pandemic broken down by professional type.
|Table 1: Summary of the top six challenges faced by university personnel at the start of the pandemic in India|
Click here to view
[Table 2] discusses key challenges faced by the students at the start of the pandemic from the perspective of faculty members.
The challenges faced by both faculty members and students, again from the perspective of faculty members, included:
- Extending duty hours for final-year students to provide additional care due to the COVID-19 pandemic
- Rapid increase in health issues among both faculty members and students due to lack of physical activity
- Lack of finances to purchase the necessary ICT products
- Lack of skills initially to conduct teaching sessions and presentations online.
[Table 3] includes the top six responses from faculty members among the various universities regarding the activities they undertook in response to the pandemic, with [Table 4] discussing other support measures. Typically, a range of support measures were introduced to assist with e-learning and the challenges.
|Table 3: Summary of immediate responses among the heath educational institutes at the start of the pandemic|
Click here to view
|Table 4: Examples of support and other measures harnessed by health educational institutions in India in response to pandemic|
Click here to view
Additional measures mentioned by faculty members to address the challenges posed by the shift to e-learning approaches for both faculty members and students included:
- Recording of lectures/tutorials to make up for loss of study times and where there are challenges in the home environment with, for instance, quiet rooms to study
- Regular screening of both faculty members and students attending teaching and clinical/practical sessions in person by regularly measuring temperatures or via rt-PCR
- Institutions providing ICT support to pertinent students, especially those struggling with available finances.
Examples of simulated methods of teaching among those surveyed included dummy objects and patients being used to explain many clinical procedures, online demonstrations to impart clinical skills and the availability of videos relating to pertinent clinical procedures. The surveyed universities also typically instigated courses/tutorials early in the pandemic for faculty members to become familiar with new platforms such as Zoom® [Box 1].
| Discussion|| |
This pilot study showed that there were considerable challenges with the introduction of e-learning among healthcare students in India at the start of the pandemic, especially those attending public universities [Table 1]. This included a lack of practicals and bedside teaching, certainly initially, compromising the ability of students when faced with patients in a real-life situation postgraduation. This mirrors the situation in other studies conducted in India and other LMICs.,,,,,,, For instance, in Egypt, the greatest barriers to e-learning approaches were inadequate/wobbly internet connections, scarcity of appropriate ICT, especially among students, and a number of technical issues. However, once addressed, there was high acceptability for e-learning approaches enhanced by the ease of use and flexibility compared with traditional approaches. Kaur et al. also found support for e-learning among medical students at SGT Medical College. One study conducted in Malaysia also reported that 21.9% and 11.2% respectively of medical students attending a public university did not have Wi-Fi access or mobile broadband coverage at home. These are key areas to address going forward given the need for fully trained HCPs on graduation in India, and following graduation, with the rise in both infectious and non-infectious diseases across the country as well as patients with joint comorbidities.,
It was encouraging to see that there was typically a rapid move to online learning among the surveyed public universities in India with online courses for faculty members to improve their skills [Table 3] and [Box 1]. This builds on the situation seen among the surveyed private universities, with on-going activities mirroring those proposed by others in India to address current challenges., As seen, limited familiarity with online learning approaches at the start of the pandemic was more of an issue among public universities [Table 1], although this is now being addressed [Table 3]. It was also encouraging to see that while there were concerns with the necessary equipment and affordable internet bundles among students [Table 2], this was less of an issue in India than seen across Africa as well as in Bangladesh and some Central and Eastern European countries.,, However, this still needs to be addressed building on current initiatives [Table 4] as hybrid learning approaches are almost certainly here to stay in the post-digital era as well as for future pandemics.,,,,,, However, new digital approaches need to be fully evaluated to meet the desired purpose given on-going concerns versus conventional learning approaches., Other areas to address in India and wider for future pandemics include addressing concerns with interpersonal interactions among healthcare students during a pandemic as well as mental health issues among both faculty members and students arising from lockdown and other measures.,,,
The introduction of a variety of measures to address identified concerns including practical teaching sessions is also encouraging for the future [Table 4], and we will be exploring this further in the full study. We have also seen final-year medical students and pre-PG doctors in India being used to manage patients with COVID-19 during the current pandemic,, and COVID-19 response field placements in other countries. Such activities should help address concerns with skills shortages on graduation.
The next stage of the research will be conducting a larger study among a variety of healthcare professionals across India to provide future guidance building on the findings of this pilot study. We will be using the same questionnaire given the depth of responses already ascertained.
We were aware of a number of limitations with this study. These included the fact that this is only a pilot study. Second, the faculty members were purposely approached to meet the aims and objectives of the study. Third, we did not approach any students for the reasons discussed. Despite these limitations, we believe that the findings are robust given the range of contributors included in the study and their responses, which are already providing direction for the future.
| Conclusions|| |
There were a number of concerns among both faculty members and healthcare students at the start of the pandemic when universities were closed. These included concerns with a lack of familiarity with e-learning approaches, especially among public universities. There were also concerns with lack of ICT equipment and affordability of internet bundles, especially among students at public universities. However, this is beginning to change providing direction for the future. The next steps will be a more complete study among HCPs to provide a more complete picture for future guidance with e-learning approaches here to stay in this post-digital era, and patients are likely to become more complex.
Financial support and sponsorship
Conflicts of interest
There are no conflicts of interest.
| References|| |
Wu Z, McGoogan JM. Characteristics of and important lessons from the coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) outbreak in China: Summary of a report of 72 314 cases from the Chinese Center for disease control and prevention. Jama 2020;323:1239-42.
WHO. WHO Coronavirus (COVID-19) Dashboard. 2022. Available from: https://covid19.who.int/
. [Last accessed on 2022 Feb 07].
Haque M, Kumar S, Charan J, Bhatt R, Islam S, Dutta S, et al.
Utilisation, availability and price changes of medicines and protection equipment for COVID-19 in India: Findings and implications. Front Pharmacol 2021;11:582154.
Recovery Collaborative Group; Horby P, Mafham M, Linsell L, Bell JL, Staplin N, et al.
Effect of hydroxychloroquine in hospitalized patients with COVID-19. N Engl J Med 2020;383:2030-40.
Dyer O. COVID-19: Remdesivir has little or no impact on survival, WHO trial shows. Bmj 2020;371:m4057.
Abubakar AR, Sani IH, Godman B, Kumar S, Islam S, Jahan I, et al.
Systematic review on the therapeutic options for COVID-19: Clinical evidence of drug efficacy and implications. Infect Drug Resist 2020;13:4673-95.
Ng Y, Li Z, Chua YX, Chaw WL, Zhao Z, Er B, et al.
Evaluation of the effectiveness of surveillance and containment measures for the first 100 patients with COVID-19 in Singapore – January 2-February 29, 2020. MMWR Morb Mortal Wkly Rep 2020;69:307-11.
Ogunleye OO, Basu D, Mueller D, Sneddon J, Seaton RA, Yinka-Ogunleye AF, et al.
Response to the novel corona virus (COVID-19) pandemic across Africa: Successes, challenges, and implications for the future. Front Pharmacol 2020;11:1205.
Dedeilia A, Sotiropoulos MG, Hanrahan JG, Janga D, Dedeilias P, Sideris M. Medical and surgical education challenges and innovations in the COVID-19 Era: A systematic review. In vivo
Godman B, Haque M, Islam S, Iqbal S, Urmi UL, Kamal ZM, et al.
Rapid assessment of price instability and paucity of medicines and protection for COVID-19 across Asia: Findings and public health implications for the future. Front Public Health 2020;8:585832.
Krishan K, Kanchan T. Lockdown is an effective 'vaccine' against COVID-19: A message from India. J Infect Dev Ctries 2020;14:545-6.
Debnath M, Ojha S, Niraula A, Sharma D. Perceptions of medical and allied health students towards online education during the COVID-19 pandemic phases and its future impact in India. J Eur CME 2021;10:1993428.
Dhingra S, Pasricha N, Sthapak E, Bhatnagar R. Assessing the role of internal motivation and extrinsic factors on online undergraduate medical teaching in a resource-poor setting during COVID-19 pandemic in North India: An observational study. Adv Med Educ Pract 2021;12:817-23.
Miloshevska L, Gajek E, Džanić ND, Hatipoğlu Ç. Emergency online learning during the first COVID-19 period: Students' perspectives from Bosnia and Herzegovina, North Macedonia, Poland and Turkey. Exell 2020;8:110-43.
Etando A, Amu AA, Haque M, Schellack N, Kurdi A, Alrasheedy AA, et al.
Challenges and innovations brought about by the COVID-19 pandemic regarding medical and pharmacy education especially in Africa and implications for the future. Healthcare 2021;9:1722.
Kunin M, Julliard KN, Rodriguez TE. Comparing face-to-face, synchronous, and asynchronous learning: Postgraduate dental resident preferences. J Dent Educ 2014;78:856-66.
McLean SF. Case-based learning and its application in medical and health-care fields: A review of worldwide literature. J Med Educ Curric Dev 2016;3:JMECD.S20377.
Chan AW, Chair SY, Sit JW, Wong EM, Lee DT, Fung OW. Case-based web learning versus face-to-face learning: A mixed-method study on University Nursing Students. J Nurs Res 2016;24:31-40.
Alsoufi A, Alsuyihili A, Msherghi A, Elhadi A, Atiyah H, Ashini A, et al.
Impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on medical education: Medical students' knowledge, attitudes, and practices regarding electronic learning. PLoS One 2020;15:e0242905.
Laloo R, Santhosh Karri R, Wanigasooriya K, Beedham W, Darr A, Layton GR, et al.
The perceived global impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on doctors' medical and surgical training: An international survey. Int J Clin Pract 2021;75:e14314.
Atreya A, Acharya J. Distant virtual medical education during COVID-19: Half a loaf of bread. Clin Teach 2020;17:418-9.
Kaur N, Dwivedi D, Arora J, Gandhi A. Study of the effectiveness of e-learning to conventional teaching in medical undergraduates amid COVID-19 pandemic. Natl J Physiol Pharm Pharmacol 2020;10:563-7.
Thapa P, Bhandari SL, Pathak S. Nursing students' attitude on the practice of e-learning: A cross-sectional survey amid COVID-19 in Nepal. PLoS One 2021;16:e0253651.
Mourya DT, Yadav PD, Ullas PT, Bhardwaj SD, Sahay RR, Chadha MS, et al.
Emerging/re-emerging viral diseases & new viruses on the Indian horizon. Indian J Med Res 2019;149:447-67.
] [Full text]
Farooqui HH, Selvaraj S, Mehta A, Heymann DL. Community level antibiotic utilization in India and its comparison vis-à-vis European countries: Evidence from pharmaceutical sales data. PLoS One 2018;13:e0204805.
Van Boeckel TP, Gandra S, Ashok A, Caudron Q, Grenfell BT, Levin SA, et al.
Global antibiotic consumption 2000 to 2010: An analysis of national pharmaceutical sales data. Lancet Infect Dis 2014;14:742-50.
McGettigan P, Roderick P, Kadam A, Pollock AM. Access, watch, and reserve antibiotics in India: Challenges for WHO stewardship. Lancet Glob Health 2017;5:e1075-6.
Kotwani A, Joshi J, Lamkang AS, Sharma A, Kaloni D. Knowledge and behavior of consumers towards the non-prescription purchase of antibiotics: An insight from a qualitative study from New Delhi, India. Pharm Pract (Granada) 2021;19:2206.
Gandra S, Kotwani A. Need to improve availability of “access” group antibiotics and reduce the use of “watch” group antibiotics in India for optimum use of antibiotics to contain antimicrobial resistance. J Pharm Policy Pract 2019;12:20.
Bhuvaraghan A, King R, Larvin H, Aggarwal VR. Antibiotic use and misuse in dentistry in India – A systematic review. Antibiotics 2021;10:1459.
George J. Antibiotics in India. Br Dent J 2020;228:60.
Ray A, Najmi A, Khandelwal G, Sadasivam B. A cost variation analysis of drugs available in the Indian Market for the Management of Thromboembolic Disorders. Cureus 2020;12:e7964.
Selvaraj S, Farooqui HH, Karan A. Quantifying the financial burden of households' out-of-pocket payments on medicines in India: A repeated cross-sectional analysis of National Sample Survey data, 1994-2014. BMJ Open 2018;8:e018020.
Kastor A, Mohanty SK. Disease-specific out-of-pocket and catastrophic health expenditure on hospitalization in India: Do Indian households face distress health financing? PLoS One 2018;13:e0196106.
Satheesh G, Puthean S, Chaudhary V. E-pharmacies in India: Can they improve the pharmaceutical service delivery? J Glob Health 2019;10:010301.
Sood N, Wagner Z. India's historic effort to expand health insurance to individuals living below the poverty line. JAMA Health Forum 2020;1:e200229.
Reddy KS. Health care reforms in India. JAMA 2018;319:2477-8.
Singh SK, Sengupta S, Antony R, Bhattacharya S, Mukhopadhyay C, Ramasubramanian V, et al.
Variations in antibiotic use across India: Multi-centre study through Global Point Prevalence survey. J Hosp Infect 2019;103:280-3.
Gandra S, Singh SK, Jinka DR, Kanithi R, Chikkappa AK, Sharma A, et al.
Point prevalence surveys of antimicrobial use among hospitalized children in six hospitals in India in 2016. Antibiotics 2017;6:19.
Langford BJ, So M, Raybardhan S, Leung V, Soucy JR, Westwood D, et al.
Antibiotic prescribing in patients with COVID-19: Rapid review and meta-analysis. Clin Microbiol Infect 2021;27:520-31.
Mustafa ZU, Saleem MS, Ikram MN, Salman M, Butt SA, Khan S, et al.
Co-infections and antimicrobial use among hospitalized COVID-19 patients in Punjab, Pakistan: Findings from a multicenter, point prevalence survey. Pathog Glob Health 2021:1-7.
Lansbury L, Lim B, Baskaran V, Lim WS. Co-infections in people with COVID-19: A systematic review and meta-analysis. J Infect 2020;81:266-75.
Kumar S, Haque M, Shetty A, Acharya J, Kumar M, Sinha V, et al
. Current management of children with COVID-19 in hospitals in India; Pilot study and findings. Adv Hum Biol 2022;12:16-21. [Full text]
Chowdhury K, Haque M, Nusrat N, Adnan N, Islam S, Lutfor AB, et al.
Management of children admitted to hospitals across Bangladesh with suspected or confirmed COVID-19 and the implications for the future: A Nationwide cross-sectional study. Antibiotics (Basel) 2022;11:105.
Founou RC, Founou LL, Essack SY. Clinical and economic impact of antibiotic resistance in developing countries: A systematic review and meta-analysis. PLoS One 2017;12:e0189621.
Hofer U. The cost of antimicrobial resistance. Nat Rev Microbiol 2019;17:3.
Godman B, Egwuenu A, Haque M, Malande OO, Schellack N, Kumar S, et al.
Strategies to improve antimicrobial utilization with a special focus on developing countries. Life (Basel) 2021;11:528.
Hsu J. How COVID-19 is accelerating the threat of antimicrobial resistance. BMJ 2020;369:m1983.
Lai CC, Chen SY, Ko WC, Hsueh PR. Increased antimicrobial resistance during the COVID-19 pandemic. Int J Antimicrob Agents 2021;57:106324.
Akpan MR, Isemin NU, Udoh AE, Ashiru-Oredope D. Implementation of antimicrobial stewardship programmes in African countries: A systematic literature review. J Glob Antimicrob Resist 2020;22:317-24.
Cox JA, Vlieghe E, Mendelson M, Wertheim H, Ndegwa L, Villegas MV, et al.
Antibiotic stewardship in low- and middle-income countries: The same but different? Clin Microbiol Infect 2017;23:812-8.
Haque M, Godman B. Potential strategies to improve antimicrobial utilisation in hospitals in Bangladesh building on experiences across developing countries. Bangladesh J Med Sci 2021;19:469-77.
Kalungia AC, Mwambula H, Munkombwe D, Marshall S, Schellack N, May C, et al.
Antimicrobial stewardship knowledge and perception among physicians and pharmacists at leading tertiary teaching hospitals in Zambia: Implications for future policy and practice. J Chemother 2019;31:378-87.
Majumder MA, Singh K, Hilaire MG, Rahman S, Sa B, Haque M. Tackling antimicrobial resistance by promoting antimicrobial stewardship in medical and allied health professional curricula. Expert Rev Anti Infect Ther 2020;18:1245-58.
Haque M, Rahman NA, McKimm J, Binti Abdullah SL, Islam MZ, Zulkifli Z, et al.
A cross-sectional study evaluating the knowledge and beliefs about, and the use of antibiotics amongst Malaysian university students. Expert Rev Anti Infect Ther 2019;17:275-84.
Godman B, Haque M, McKimm J, Abu Bakar M, Sneddon J, Wale J, et al.
Ongoing strategies to improve the management of upper respiratory tract infections and reduce inappropriate antibiotic use particularly among lower and middle-income countries: Findings and implications for the future. Curr Med Res Opin 2020;36:301-27.
Mukokinya MM, Opanga S, Oluka M, Godman B. Dispensing of antimicrobials in Kenya: A cross-sectional pilot study and its implications. J Res Pharm Pract 2018;7:77-82.
] [Full text]
Opanga SA, Rizvi N, Wamaitha A, Sefah IA, Godman B. Availability of medicines in community pharmacy to manage patients with COVID-19 in Kenya; Pilot study and implications. Sch Acad J Pharm 2021;10:36-42.
Marković-Peković V, Grubiša N, Burger J, Bojanić L, Godman B. Initiatives to reduce nonprescription sales and dispensing of antibiotics: Findings and implications. J Res Pharm Pract 2017;6:120-5.
Godman B. Combating COVID-19: Lessons learnt particularly among developing countries and the implications. Bangladesh J Med Sci 2020;19:S103-8.
Cadogan CA, Hughes CM. On the frontline against COVID-19: Community pharmacists' contribution during a public health crisis. Res Social Adm Pharm 2021;17:2032-5.
Hedima EW, Adeyemi MS, Ikunaiye NY. Community pharmacists: On the frontline of health service against COVID-19 in LMICs. Res Social Adm Pharm 2021;17:1964-6.
Abena PM, Decloedt EH, Bottieau E, Suleman F, Adejumo P, Sam-Agudu NA, et al.
Chloroquine and hydroxychloroquine for the prevention or treatment of COVID-19 in Africa: Caution for inappropriate off-label use in healthcare settings. Am J Trop Med Hyg 2020;102:1184-8.
Haque M, Abubakar AR, Ogunleye OO, Sani IH, Sefah I, Kurdi A, et al.
Changes in availability, utilization, and prices of medicines and protection equipment for COVID-19 in an Urban population of Northern Nigeria. J Res Pharm Pract 2021;10:17-22. [Full text]
Haque M, Islam S, Iqbal S, Urmi UL, Kamal ZM, Shuvo SA, et al.
Availability and price changes of potential medicines and equipment for the prevention and treatment of COVID-19 among pharmacy and drug stores in Bangladesh; findings and implications. Bangladesh J Med Sci 2020;19:S36-50.
Shahwan M, Suliman A, Abdulrahman Jairoun A, Alkhoujah S, Al-Hemyari SS, Al-Tamimi SK, et al.
Prevalence, knowledge and potential determinants of COVID-19 vaccine acceptability among University students in the United Arab Emirates: Findings and implications. J Multidiscip Healthc 2022;15:81-92.
Mohan P, Mohan SB, Dutta M. Communicable or noncommunicable diseases? Building strong primary health care systems to address double burden of disease in India. J Family Med Prim Care 2019;8:326-9.
] [Full text]
Arokiasamy P. India's escalating burden of non-communicable diseases. Lancet Glob Health 2018;6:e1262-3.
India State-Level Disease Burden Initiative CVD Collaborators. The changing patterns of cardiovascular diseases and their risk factors in the states of India: The Global Burden of Disease Study 1990-2016. Lancet Glob Health 2018;6:e1339-51.
Chan JC, Lim LL, Wareham NJ, Shaw JE, Orchard TJ, Zhang P, et al.
The Lancet Commission on diabetes: Using data to transform diabetes care and patient lives. Lancet 2021;396:2019-82.
Al-Arkee S, Mason J, Lane DA, Fabritz L, Chua W, Haque MS, et al.
Mobile apps to improve medication adherence in cardiovascular disease: Systematic review and meta-analysis. J Med Internet Res 2021;23:e24190.
Kretchy IA, Asiedu-Danso M, Kretchy JP. Medication management and adherence during the COVID-19 pandemic: Perspectives and experiences from low-and middle-income countries. Res Social Adm Pharm 2021;17:2023-6.
Torres-Robles A, Benrimoj SI, Gastelurrutia MA, Martinez-Martinez F, Peiro T, Perez-Escamilla B, et al.
Effectiveness of a medication adherence management intervention in a community pharmacy setting: A cluster randomised controlled trial. BMJ Qual Saf 2022;31:105-15.
Institute of Medicine Committee on Assuring the Health of the Public in the 21st
C. The Future of the Public's Health in the 21st
Century. Washington (DC): National Academies Press (US); 2002.
Mukhtar K, Javed K, Arooj M, Sethi A. Advantages, Limitations and Recommendations for online learning during COVID-19 pandemic era. Pak J Med Sci 2020;36:S27-31.
Nimavat N, Singh S, Fichadiya N, Sharma P, Patel N, Kumar M, et al.
Online medical education in India – Different challenges and probable solutions in the age of COVID-19. Adv Med Educ Pract 2021;12:237-43.
Gaur U, Majumder MA, Sa B, Sarkar S, Williams A, Singh K. Challenges and opportunities of preclinical medical education: COVID-19 crisis and beyond. SN Compr Clin Med 2020;2:1992-7.
Ray I, Agarwal V, Agarwal T, Pande A. Medical student's perspective regarding undergraduate surgical education with special reference to pandemic. Indian J Surg 2021;1-5.
Akers A, Blough C, Iyer MS. COVID-19 implications on clinical clerkships and the residency application process for medical students. Cureus 2020;12:e7800.
Tariq EF, Sah PK, Malik A. The plight of COVID-19 pandemic on medical students and residency applicants. Ann Med Surg (Lond) 2020;60:1-4.
TMS Collaborative. The perceived impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on medical student education and training – An international survey. BMC Med Educ 2021;21:566.
Ng L, Seow KC, MacDonald L, Correia C, Reubenson A, Gardner P, et al.
eLearning in physical therapy: Lessons learned from transitioning a professional education program to full elearning during the COVID-19 pandemic. Phys Ther 2021;101:pzab082.
Iurcov R, Pop LM, Iorga M. Impact of COVID-19 pandemic on academic activity and health status among romanian medical dentistry students; a cross-sectional study. Int J Environ Res Public Health 2021;18:6041.
Chinna K, Sundarasen S, Khoshaim HB, Kamaludin K, Nurunnabi M, Baloch GM, et al.
Psychological impact of COVID-19 and lock down measures: An online cross-sectional multicounty study on Asian university students. PLoS One 2021;16:e0253059.
Khalili H. Online interprofessional education during and post the COVID-19 pandemic: A commentary. J Interprof Care 2020;34:687-90.
Chandratre S. Medical students and COVID-19: Challenges and supportive strategies. J Med Educ Curric Dev 2020;7:2382120520935059.
Saraswathi I, Saikarthik J, Senthil Kumar K, Madhan Srinivasan K, Ardhanaari M, Gunapriya R. Impact of COVID-19 outbreak on the mental health status of undergraduate medical students in a COVID-19 treating medical college: A prospective longitudinal study. PeerJ 2020;8:e10164.
Alrasheedy AA, Abdulsalim S, Farooqui M, Alsahali S, Godman B. Knowledge, attitude and practice about coronavirus disease (COVID-19) pandemic and its psychological impact on students and their studies: A cross-sectional study among pharmacy students in Saudi Arabia. Risk Manag Healthc Policy 2021;14:729-41.
Soliman M, Aldhaheri S, Neel K. Experience from a medical college in Saudi Arabia on undergraduate curriculum management and delivery during COVID-19 pandemic. J Nat Sci Med 2021;4:85-9. [Full text]
Al-Terri D, Hindi MN, AlMarar R, Shubair RM, editors. Transition to distance learning during the COVID-19 pandemic: Efforts within the Higher Education sector in the United Arab Emirates. Journal of Applied Learning and Teaching 2020;3:31-9.
Chowdhury K, Etando A, Shahwan M, Škrbić R, Jairoun AA, Haque M, et al
. COVID-19 and the impact on the education of healthcare professionals across countries with a particular focus on developing countries. Bangladesh J Med Sci 2022;21:221-32.
Abbasi MS, Ahmed N, Sajjad B, Alshahrani A, Saeed S, Sarfaraz S, et al.
E-Learning perception and satisfaction among health sciences students amid the COVID-19 pandemic. Work 2020;67:549-56.
Besche H, Schwartz AW, Cockrill B. Ensuring equitable access to remote learning during the COVID-19 Pandemic. Acad Med 2021;96:e19-20.
Gupta S, Dabas A, Swarnim S, Mishra D. Medical education during COVID-19 associated lockdown: Faculty and students' perspective. Med J Armed Forces India 2021;77 Suppl 1:S79-84.
Nambiar D. The impact of online learning during COVID-19: Students' and teachers' perspective. Int J Indian Psychol 2020;8:783-93.
Saurabh MK, Patel T, Bhabhor P, Patel P, Kumar S. Students' perception on online teaching and learning during COVID-19 pandemic in medical education. Maedica (Bucur) 2021;16:439-44.
Agarwal S, Kaushik JS. Student's perception of online learning during COVID pandemic. Indian J Pediatr 2020;87:554.
Vishwanathan K, Patel GM, Patel DJ. Impact and perception about distant online medical education (tele-education) on the educational environment during the COVID-19 pandemic: Experiences of medical undergraduate students from India. J Family Med Prim Care 2021;10:2216-24. [Full text]
Gardas S, Nair S, Pitchai P, Panhale V. Postgraduate physiotherapy training in a quandary – Ramifications of corona virus pandemic lockdown: A survey-based study. J Adv Med Educ Prof 2021;9:144-53.
Upadhyaya GK, Jain VK, Iyengar KP, Patralekh MK, Vaish A. Impact of COVID-19 on post-graduate orthopaedic training in Delhi-NCR. J Clin Orthop Trauma 2020;11:S687-95.
Jain VK, Upadhyaya GK, Iyengar KP, Patralekh MK, Lal H, Vaishya R. Impact of COVID-19 on clinical practices during lockdown: A pan India survey of orthopaedic surgeons. Malays Orthop J 2021;15:55-62.
Megaloikonomos PD, Thaler M, Igoumenou VG, Bonanzinga T, Ostojic M, Couto AF, et al.
Impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on orthopaedic and trauma surgery training in Europe. Int Orthop 2020;44:1611-9.
Boekhorst F, Khattak H, Topcu EG, Horala A, Gonçalves Henriques M. The influence of the COVID-19 outbreak on European trainees in obstetrics and gynaecology: A survey of the impact on training and trainee. Eur J Obstet Gynecol Reprod Biol 2021;261:52-8.
Chowdhury K, Haque M, Lutfor AB, Siddiqui TH, Ahmad R, Sultana I, et al
. Impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on dental and medical education in Bangladesh: A pilot study and the implications. Bangladesh J Med Sci 2022;21:451-61.
Sulania A, Singh S, Goel S. The new 2019 medical curriculum in india; in light of the integration of medical curriculum. Journal of Medical Education 2019;18:251-9.
Sabde Y, Diwan V, Mahadik VK, Parashar V, Negandhi H, Trushna T, et al.
Medical schools in India: Pattern of establishment and impact on public health – A Geographic Information System (GIS) based exploratory study. BMC Public Health 2020;20:755.
Samuel SR. Dental education: Too many graduates in India. Br Dent J 2016;220:219.
Gambhir RS, Gupta T. Need for oral health policy in India. Ann Med Health Sci Res 2016;6:50-5.
] [Full text]
Dental Council of India. Welcome to the Dental Council of India; 2021. Available from: https://dciindia.gov.in/
. [Last accessed 2022 Feb 03].
Pharmacy Council of India, New Delhi (Constituted under the Pharmacy Act, 1948). Rules & Syllabus for the Bachelor of Pharmacy (BPharm) Course [Framed under Regulation 6, 7 & 8 of the Bachelor of Pharmacy (B. Pharm) course regulations 2014]. Available from: https://www.pci.nic.in/pdf/Syllabus_B_Pharm.pdf
. [Last accessed 2022 Feb03].
Singh HK, Joshi A, Malepati RN, Najeeb S, Balakrishna P, Pannerselvam NK, et al.
A survey of E-learning methods in nursing and medical education during COVID-19 pandemic in India. Nurse Educ Today 2021;99:104796.
Godman B, Basu D, Pillay Y, Mwita JC, Rwegerera GM, Anand Paramadhas BD, et al.
Review of ongoing activities and challenges to improve the care of patients with type 2 diabetes across Africa and the implications for the future. Front Pharmacol 2020;11:108.
Godman B, Haque M, Leong T, Allocati E, Kumar S, Islam S, et al.
The current situation regarding long-acting insulin analogues including biosimilars Among African, Asian, European, and South American Countries; Findings and implications for the future. Front Public Health 2021;9:671961.
Parija S, Das S. COVID-19 and the medical education system in ophthalmology – Lessons learned and future directions. Indian J Ophthalmol 2021;69:1332-3.
] [Full text]
Zalat MM, Hamed MS, Bolbol SA. The experiences, challenges, and acceptance of e-learning as a tool for teaching during the COVID-19 pandemic among university medical staff. PLoS One 2021;16:e0248758.
Roslan N, Halim A. Enablers and barriers to online learning among medical students during COVID-19 pandemic: An explanatory mixed-method study. Sustainability 2021;13:6086.
Sholl S, Ajjawi R, Allbutt H, Butler J, Jindal-Snape D, Morrison J, et al.
Balancing health care education and patient care in the UK workplace: A realist synthesis. Med Educ 2017;51:787-801.
Sarkar A, Saha PK, Bagga R. Effects of the COVID-19 pandemic on post graduate gynecological training and surgical skills: Indian perspective. Obstet Gynecol Sci 2021;64:467-9.
Rapanta C, Botturi L, Goodyear P, Guàrdia L, Koole M. Online University teaching during and after the COVID-19 Crisis: Refocusing teacher presence and learning activity. Postdigital Sci Educ 2020;1-23.
Singh J, Steele K, Singh L. Combining the best of online and face-to-face learning: Hybrid and blended learning approach for COVID-19, post vaccine, & post-pandemic World. J Educ Technol Syst 2021;50:140-71.
Chick RC, Clifton GT, Peace KM, Propper BW, Hale DF, Alseidi AA, et al.
Using technology to maintain the education of residents during the COVID-19 pandemic. J Surg Educ 2020;77:729-32.
Rajab MH, Gazal AM, Alkattan K. Challenges to online medical education during the COVID-19 pandemic. Cureus 2020;12:e8966.
Dhawan S. Online Learning: A panacea in the time of COVID-19 crisis. J Educ Technol Syst 2020;49:5-22.
Hameed T, Husain M, Jain SK, Singh CB, Khan S. Online medical teaching in COVID-19 Era: Experience and perception of undergraduate students. Maedica 2020;15:440-4.
Altillo BS, Gray M, Avashia SB, Norwood A, Nelson EA, Johnston C, et al.
Global health on the front lines: An innovative medical student elective combining education and service during the COVID-19 pandemic. BMC Med Educ 2021;21:186.
[Table 1], [Table 2], [Table 3], [Table 4], [Table 1], [Table 2], [Table 3], [Table 4]